INST 734
Information Retrieval Systems
Spring 2018
Exercise E1
Try out three search systems from the list below and, for each,
answer the questions that follow the list of systems. Be sure to try
several types of searches (e.g., your personal interest, imagined
academic or professional information needs, searches you see in Web
logs, etc.) and to explore both basic and advanced search features
(when the system provides multiple modes).
Here are the questions:
- How easy was it for you to learn to use the system?
- How useful would the system be in the hands of a subject matter
expert (i.e., someone who knows their task well, and who knows
the right words to use for things) but who is not a professional
searcher (and thus does not have specific training in search
strategies or in the query language of this particular system)?
- How useful would the system be in the hands of a professional
searcher who is not a subject matter expert?
- How well were you able to determine what the system did and did
have in its index? In other words, after you have completed a
search, do you have a good sense for whether searching here had
been sufficient or whether you would also need to use other
search services that cover similar content if you really wanted
to be sure you had done a comprehensive search?
- How well do you think you were able to control the balance
between comprehensiveness with which the system searched the
collection it does have indexed (recall) and the suppression of
unwanted results from display to you (precision)?
You can take either a comparative (System A is better than System B
for question 2) or absolute (System A was suitable for tasks a and b,
but not c) approach to constructing your answer -- whichever style you
prefer. Grading of this assignment will be done holistically, based
on whether you uncovered interesting issues that could help to guide
your exploration of system design issues this semester. This exercise
should take you 2-3 hours, including writing up your answers to the
questions).
After completing your assignment, please also write a paragraph
introducing yourself to me and to your classmates. In this paragraph,
please summarize which program you are in here (MIM, MLS, HCIM, Ph.D.,
something else?), what previous degree(s) you have earned, what
computer programming languages you know (if any), why you are taking
this class, what you hope to learn, and something interesting about
yourself.
Please also look at the 20 readings in the "assigned
summaries" for modules 2, 3, 4 and 5 (you can easily reach these
from the schedule page) and let me know, in most-preferred-first order
which 5 you would be most interested in reading. I will try to assign
you one of those five. You must select at least one from each module
(because if I didn't add this restriction, nobody would pick one from
module 2!).
You should submit your assignment on ELMS. Instructions for doing
this are on the course ELMS site.
Doug Oard
Last modified: Sun Feb 25 19:00:52 2018